Add your email and we'll match picks to the services you stream at home.

Poster for Brothers O'Toole

Brothers O'Toole

Seen it?

1973 | 95 min | Western, Comedy

Weeknight Watchearly rating

Why it’s a Weeknight Watch

With almost no lasting buzz and soft box office, it's a mixed bag. Fine if it's on; don't plan your night around it.

Based on critics, audiences, awards, box office and buzz. Details below.

Is it for you?

Who'll love it
Made for anyone who wants a laugh.
The mood
Light and funny.
The pace
Breezy, at 1 hr 35 min.
What might put you off
Made in 1973: an older pace and style.

The O'Toole Brothers are Eastern con men, exceptionally good at talking their way out of tight situations. When they ride into Molybdenum, Colorado, not suspecting the riches beneath the streets, they turn the sleepy mining town upside-down for their search for the gold. High-spirited hijinks ensue, with the brothers involved in everything from stolen gambling equipment to a "belchin', cussin' and spittin' " contest.

How it earned its rating

  • CriticsSolid

    Generally positive reviews

  • AudiencesNot counted

    Not measured yet: not enough ratings

  • AwardsNot counted

    No major awards or nominations

  • Box office & staying powerBelow par

    $300K worldwide; still draws a steady audience long after release

  • Buzz & cultural impactWeak

    About 3K people sought it out in the past year

More like this

Want more like this, picked just for you? Get my picks

Cast & crew

Directed by Richard Erdman

  • John AstinMichael O'Toole
  • Pat CarrollCallie Burdyne
  • Hans ConriedPolonius Vandergelt
  • Richard ErdmanJudge Quincey P. Trumbell
  • Allyn JoslynSheriff Ed Hatfield
  • Richard JuryHarmon P. Lovejoy
  • Lee MeriwetherPaloma Littleberry
  • Jesse WhiteMayor
  • Steve CarlsonTimothy O'Toole
  • Miranda BarryBonnie Lou MacClanahan